by Simon Sheppard
Not every gay man is a slim, smooth, clean-shaven guy in his 20s -- though
it sometimes seems that way. Back in the mid-1980s, when the dictatorship of
the gym bunny seemed to reign supreme, along lumbered the bears, their big,
furry bodies oozing lust. Utterly unlike those twink models in gay fashion
magazines, your basic bear is bearded (often bushily), heavier (and sometimes,
frankly, fat), older, usually clad in comfy denim or leather, and, in theory
at least, exuding an unforced masculinity.
One bi-coastal cub of my acquaintance, a cute, furry Italian with a pretty
dick, says, "The bear thing's more popular now than it has ever been. I
think it's regionally based, more so in places like San Francisco, less so in
places like Boston, but more popular across the board."
Sure, some guys were always into men with bigger bodies; they used to call
'em "chubby chasers." But the bear phenomenon, as movement, cult, or
community, is really something new. At a time when AIDS has made gay men's
relationships to our bodies problematic, the bear mystique celebrates the
sexiness of flesh.
Bear sexuality emphasizes a nurturing escape from the competitive
heartlessness that's found in other parts of the queer community. As Les
Wright writes in The Bear Book, "A bear attitude ... seeks out and
promotes emotional intimacy in sexual encounters ... and sustained primary
relationships while accommodating the realities of casual sex -- fuck buddies,
tricks, play partners, and the like."
It's a cultural phenomenon unique to the gay community, too. Some straight
guys fetishize larger women, but gay bear culture is about more than what
makes you hard. Since the early days of Bear magazine (with its breezy motto,
"Naked hairy homo smut"), there's been a veritable bear invasion:
bear bars, bear books and magazines, events like Chicago's Bear Pride, the
inevitable shelves of bear merchandise, and the makings of a subculture within
the gay subculture. And then there are the subgroups within the subgroup --
cubs (younger bears, natch), otters (thinner hairy guys), and muscle bears
(pretty much what it sounds like).
So beardom is somewhat of a cross between a social movement and a sexual
fetish. Like all social movements, there are internal disagreements, and some
bears endlessly debate who is and who isn't a "real" bear. What
really counts: size, hairiness, attitude? There's even a rating scale that
someone has come up with, giving numerical values to things like the bushiness
of a guy's beard and the girth of his belly.
And, like any sexual fetish, the attraction of bear types may baffle guys
who aren't into it. But sexiness is, to a good extent, a culturally determined
phenomenon. What's supposed to be hard-on-producing changes with time: many a
'70s porn star, with hairy chest and non-steroid body, looks positively
old-fashioned. But, like platform shoes, all sorts of fashions get revived.
Bears have taken elements of things that have had sexual value -- the
outdoorsy look of the Castro clone, the male signifiers of body hair and
beards -- and added an emphasis on size. Not penis size, waist size.
Some complain that the rise of bear beauty contests and bear porn stars
echo the mainstream pecking order that the movement originally opposed. And
maybe that's true. But spending a Saturday night at such (in)famous bear
haunts as San Francisco's Lone Star Saloon make it clear that funloving big
guys are out in force and here to stay. And let's face it, notwithstanding the
politics, the spirituality, and the camaraderie of the bear bunch, a lot of it
still comes down to sex. Thank goodness.
"Here I am, a big guy. C'mon and screw me, buddy," says Mr. Bear.
And who are we to argue?